Typically, I’m asked to pair cheese with wine and beer. Maybe chocolate, or even cocktails. But coffee? Not your first thought when it comes to tasting with cheese.
But wait, we already pair dairy with coffee! We add milk to espresso and coffee, have cheese danish & cheesecake with our coffee… and I’ve learned that with the right cheeses, this roasted bean can make an intriguing and satisfying dance partner.
The first step is making sure you’re brewing the perfect cup of coffee. Beans should be fresh, and ground as close as possible to when you’ll actually be using them. If making french press coffee, be sure to bloom the grounds for about a minute before full steeping for four minutes. Another hugely important factor is making sure that the water isn’t too hot. For the definitive guide on brewing coffee, plus more information in general, check out Counter Culture Coffee’s guide to making coffee.
Now for the cheese. The main flavors that I look for when picking cheese to pair with coffee are threefold: nutty; caramel-y; or chocolatey. Here are four picks for cheeses that will be delicious with your bittersweet brew:
The obvious choice for a cheese to pair with coffee would be one that already blends the two. Enter Utah’s Beehive Cheese Co. They’ve created the cow’s milk Barely Buzzed, with an espresso-and-lavender-rubbed rind. Although it sounds bizarre, it works. This cheese has smooth texture with cheddar-y notes, and the rind (entirely edible!) lends a chocolatey richness. Plus, I love that this cheese is a family affair – Cheesemakers Tim & Pat are husband and wife, and the espresso beans in the rind come from Tim’s brother’s Colorado Legacy Coffee Company.
Another unique American creation is Cypress Grove Creamery’s Midnight Moon. This cheese semi-firm, flaky goat’s milk cheese is aged for at least six months, allowing it to develop and form those crunchy bits (crystallized protein) that everyone goes nuts about. Made in Holland for the California cheesemaker, it’s akin to a firmer goat gouda, with its fruity, nutty, caramel notes and dense, smooth texture.
Speaking of Gouda, try one of my faaavorite Dutch cheeses, Reypenaer. At just over two years old, this cow’s milk cheese is aged in a lofty historic warehouse on the Old Rhine river in Holland. This aging facility is one of the only ones left that doesn’t use refrigeration – it controls temperature and humidity by opening and closing wooden vents. In this way the cheese ages naturally, and has a much more complex flavor than many other Goudas. Its rich, butterscotch, caramel notes will pair wonderfully with coffee, and its firm, crunchy texture makes it a hit among cheese fans.
One of the classics, Comté (com-TAY) has rich, complex flavors that are ideal for the bittersweet notes of strong coffee. This French cheese is similar to the Swiss-made Gruyere, but much nuttier – you’ll get notes of brown butter, hazelnuts, and wildflowers. The 80-lb wheels of raw cow’s milk are produced by cooperatives and aged anywhere between 4-18 months, so the texture will range from firm yet creamy on the palate to a much denser firm cheese. Made in the Franche-Comte region just west of the Swiss border, Comté is one of the kings of Alpine-style cheeses, and I’ve yet to find a poorly-made version.
So go forth and experiment! Try any of these cheeses with your morning brew or a post-dinner espresso. And let us know in the comments section any other cheeses you find that are just as delicious with your coffee as with wine.








































